Caraval Readalong: Day 4

Beautiful photo by @thefearlessreader

Welcome, Welcome friends!

Today is day 4 of the ‘Caraval’ readalong! I’m stressed out (in the best way) from yesterday’s chapters. so much happened and we left on a bit of a cliffhanger.

For today’s Readalong we’re reading chapters 20 – 27, and stopping at the beginning of chapter 28.

Let’s continue with our Caraval adventure, shall we?

Please be warned, the following will include spoilers for Caraval chapters 20-27 inclusively. Read only if you’ve finished those chapters!


Yesterday, we left off with Scarlett dying. Yes, you read that right. Our protagonist is currently dying. But, it’s only for two days though. It’s fine guys, don’t panic. *Proceeds to panic anyway*

Scarlett runs into a rather desperate Dante on the way back to her room. He tells her that his sister is missing and before he can get another word out, Julian has punched him and went to Scarlett, worrying over her. Which makes my heart swoooon! Does anyone else notice here that he uses her actual name? Aw, Julian.

I swear I almost squealed when Julian decided to give her a day of his life, A rather intimate gesture, don’t you think? But, I love it. This whole scene, I swear my heart was in my throat and I couldn’t stop reading.

Image result for reading gif

Whilst Scarlett is essentially dead, but dreaming, she sees her grandparents. Her grandfather calls her Grandmother Annalise, which just so happens to be the name of the woman Legend was apparently in love with!

Image result for coincidence gif

They talk of a man who won the last games only to find his fiancee in bed with Legend afterwards. She broke off their engagement, claiming to be in love with Legend, but then tossed herself from a window when Legend didn’t return her feelings. Scarlett was witnessing her funeral and she spots Dante following the procession as the girl’s fiancee. She turns when Dante walks off in the direction of Legend. But when Scarlett looks, she sees Julian! Dun, dun, DUUUN!

When Scarlett wakes, she tries to get away, she thinks Julian is Legend now, or that he is more closely related to Caraval than he led her to believe. When she darts into the hall, she sees her father. The man she fears the most, before darting back into the room as Julian awakens. Despite her best efforts to act calm, Julian is hurt when she pulls away.

What would you guys do in this situation? I can be quite impatient, so I feel like I would outright accuse him of being Legend.

Julian disappears into Tella’s room and when Scarlett follows, he’s nowhere to be seen. Enter, another hidden staircase. I love a good hidden staircase!

Scarlett follows the staircase and the footsteps which we can only assume to be Julian’s. She stumbles across a hand and when she looks up, she finds Dante’s dead body, and Julian standing over it. Dante! Noooooooo!

Image result for nooooo gif

As Scarlett tries to run off, Julian catches her and explains that he and Dante were working together. Le’Gasp! He tells Scarlett that Rosa was his sister and Dante’s fiancee after she accuses him of being Legend. Scarlett believes him. For those of you who are reading for the first time, I’d love to know if you think he’s telling the truth or not?

After escaping the tunnels, Julian explains that he knew Scarlett would get a ticket as Legend planned to doom all Annalise’s heirs and marriages due to his heartbreak over her, so he knew once Scarlett was engaged, Legend would send an invite. That’s some careful planning there, Julian. You’re indeed a cunning one. He also tells her that he knew one of them would be kidnapped as part of Legend’s game. I remember being so conflicted about whether to believe Julian or not. Garber does such an amazing job of making her characters mysterious and deceiving.

Scarlett’s second dress is delivered and the card is signed by Tella, at least that’s who we think it’s signed by. I’m bloody glad she got that dress! a day off her life, and Julian’s for it? Better be worth it. Julian allows Scarlett to follow her theory about this being a clue when they run into a man in a top hat. He kisses Scarlett’s hand after she accuses him of being Legend. Honestly, anyone could be Legend at this point. 

Julian isn’t happy in the slightest about the hand kissing gesture, especially when the man reveals himself as Scarlett’s fiance!

What do you guys think of chapters 20 – 27?

This is quite the little cliffhanger to leave off on. I genuinely forgot that Scarlett’s fiance made an appearance. Ah, the beauty of re-reading your favourite books! I’m also heartbroken for Dante. This is not okay.

Again, please be mindful of spoilers if you decide to continue reading!

We will be back tomorrow and will be reading chapters 28-35.

With Love,



7 thoughts on “Caraval Readalong: Day 4

  1. Wowza! What a day! I haven’t read the book before and I just could not believe Julian to be Legend. So I do think he is telling her the truth! And the fiancee showing up! Ah gawd! Now I’m going to go read what happens next!

  2. The ending of the chapter has me freaking out again lol. I cannot believe the cliffhanger!!

  3. Well that was all dramatic and sensual. First “helped” by Dante and then Julian offers her s day of her life and they exchange blood and she wants to kiss him and then they die. Steamy.

    What!!! How much of the dream is truth. Tella appears and her grandma Annalise is shown. She must have something more to do with Caraval.
    When Dante won his fiancé Rosa fell in love with Legend. Broke off her engagement and committed suicide.
    Julian appears in the top hat. Is he Legend?

    Did her grandma leave him?

    She remembers when she wakes and fears for Tella more than herself
    Evil Daddy shows up and Julian wakes up. She rebuffs him and can now see his emotions as colours too. Then she sees him leaving Dante’s room and into Tella’s. Oooh the intrigue.

    Another secret passage. Is anyone else getting Phantom of the Opera vibes?

    Julian is standing over Dante’s dead body saying they were working together against Legend. What are we all to believe.

    He’s Rosa’s brother.

    Clever thing with the letters at the beginning where she don’t give her surname until the last one and supposedly Legend is out for revenge for Annalise’s betrayal. Julian admits he knew one of the girls would be taken by him. Does he know who the count is?

    Her second dress arrives looking like a wedding dress and she decides the buttons lead to the hat shop where she sees the guy with the eyepatch and an emerald green eye to match her emerald green promotion who says he’s her fiancé ?

    Sorry I can’t stop there. Will read on and make notes. I finished and reiterate my general ? I had forgotten so much.

  4. Clearly I need to proofread my reading notes. Sorry. ?‍♀️

  5. oh wow what a cliffhanger. Julian has won me over with taking a days death away from scarlet. how sweet. and I am now crying Dante what more can i say i am now in mourning.
    I am now going to see what happens next. still loving this book.

  6. Dante dying is just so awful. He might be moody and self-righteous, but he’s just so dark and mysterious. It’s really upsetting! ?
    And Scarlett’s finance turning up the way he does? Ah, I’ve just got to keep reading!?

  7. Phew! All these twists and turns are making me dizzy! (It’s always astounding to realize how much I forgot since my first read.) I really hate not knowing who you can trust – but at the same time I kinda love it! ? Stephanie sure knows how to keep us guessing… Also, I’m falling in love with Julian all over again. ?

Leave a Reply